Summary
In his classic commentary on Romans, Robert Haldane provides an exposition of Paul’s letter that is rooted in historic Reformed convictions: the sovereignty of God, justification by faith, the reality of human sinfulness, and the full sufficiency of Christ. The work was first delivered in Geneva in the early 19th century and was later published in book form. :contentReference[oaicite:2]{index=2}
Haldane’s approach is both exegetical and devotional: he moves verse-by-verse through the epistle, offers occasional engagement with other commentaries, and emphasises the practical implications of the doctrine for believers. His tone is earnest, warm, and pastoral rather than technically heavy. :contentReference[oaicite:3]{index=3}
This commentary serves teachers, pastors and serious students of Scripture who desire a theologically robust, Christ-centred, historically grounded reading of Romans. It may be less useful for those seeking full Greek‐text apparatus or heavily critical engagement with modern scholarship, but it more than makes up for that in devotional power and doctrinal clarity.
Why Should I Own This Commentary?
One of the strengths of Haldane’s commentary is its unwavering commitment to the primacy of Scripture and the doctrine of justification by faith. As noted by the text itself: “The great truths … are brought together in a condensed and comprehensive form.” :contentReference[oaicite:4]{index=4} This makes it a valuable resource when preaching or teaching Romans, especially where one wants to ground exposition in the historic Reformed tradition.
Another useful feature is the way Haldane weaves theological insight with pastoral application. His exposition does not stop at doctrine but leads into the life of faith: how justification shapes Christian identity, how the believer lives under grace, and how the Gospel drives worship, not merely morality. For a pastor preparing sermons or study-group leads, this commentary offers rich material for reflection and sermon outlines.
Further, because the work is older it avoids many of the technical detours of modern scholarship, making it more accessible than some of the heavier academic commentaries. That said, it still holds up theologically and continues to be commended by evangelical voices. :contentReference[oaicite:5]{index=5} Its enduring influence is a testimony to its value.
Closing Recommendation
We commend Haldane’s Romans to pastors, preachers, and mature lay‐teachers who want a doctrinally sound, theologically rich, and pastorally warm guide to Paul’s epistle. It is particularly well suited for those working from a Reformed perspective, and for anyone looking for a classic voice amid the wealth of modern commentary options.
While this is not the most up‐to‐date critical commentary, its strengths in exposition, doctrine and application are substantial. On balance, we recommend purchasing this work and placing it alongside more technical commentaries, as a reliable and edifying companion. Score: 8.5/10.