James

AdvancedAdvanced students / scholars, Busy pastors, Pastors-in-trainingTop choice
Bible Book: James
Publisher: Banner of Truth
Theological Perspective: Reformed
Resource Type: Commentary
Last updated: February 5, 2026
Looking for alternatives? Compare James commentaries.

Evaluation

Overall Score: 8.5/10

A rich and searching exposition of James that feeds preaching, strengthens holiness, and keeps grace close to obedience.

Publication Date(s): 1962
Pages: 481
ISBN: 9780851510743
Faithfulness to the Text: 9/10
We find close attention to the logic of each paragraph, with careful handling of James’s exhortations in their setting.
Christ Centredness: 8.3/10
Christ is not treated as an ornament, but as the ground of true religion, humble obedience, and persevering faith.
Depth of Insight: 8.8/10
We are helped by rich theological reflection, careful distinctions, and repeated return to the text’s central concerns.
Clarity of Writing: 8/10
The style is older, but the argument is usually clear, and the commentary is well suited to structured sermon preparation.
Pastoral Usefulness: 9.1/10
It strengthens preaching that calls for repentance and holiness without drifting into self improvement or mere moralism.
Readability: 7.8/10
Best read steadily rather than quickly, but the rewards are real for those who keep working through it.

Summary

At a Glance

Length
481 pages
Type
Expositional
Theo. Perspective
Reformed
Overall score
8.5 / 10
Strength
Deep pastoral application rooted in careful reading of James.
Limitation
The older Puritan style can feel heavy for quick weekly scanning.

We find Manton’s James in the Geneva Commentaries a substantial Puritan exposition, full of Scripture soaked reasoning and pastoral seriousness. He treats James as a letter that aims at real godliness, not empty profession.

Manton moves patiently through the text, drawing out argument, motives, and spiritual diagnosis. The result is a commentary that does not merely explain, it shepherds, probing the heart and pressing us toward repentance, faith, and steady obedience.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

We should own this commentary when we want our preaching in James to be searching and gospel shaped. Manton helps us avoid turning James into bare moral instruction, because he repeatedly anchors obedience in the grace of God and the reality of new birth.

We also benefit from his careful handling of themes that can be misused, such as faith and works, the tongue, wisdom, wealth, and suffering. He helps us keep the letter’s pastoral aim in view, so application lands as discipleship, not as scolding.

For those training to preach, it is an excellent model of how to move from text to conscience with precision, tenderness, and spiritual weight.

Closing Recommendation

We recommend this as an advanced expositional resource for preaching James, especially where we want depth, searching application, and strong pastoral instincts. It is not a quick reference tool, but it will repay sustained use over the course of a series.

As pastoral next steps, we can visit the Bible Book Overview, browse Top Recommendations, and use the Reformed Commentary Index to build a wiser working library.


Where to buy
exlib_wtb_inserted

Classification

  • Level: Advanced
  • Best For: Advanced students / scholars, Busy pastors, Pastors-in-training
  • Priority: Top choice

Build your shelf for this Bible book

Top picks connected to this Bible book, plus a few trusted global staples.

Commentary

  • Jamesby Daniel Doriani 8.6
  • Jamesby Thomas Manton 8.5
  • Jamesby Robert Johnstone 8.4

Bible Atlas

Reviewed by

An Expositor

↑ Back to the top
Previous review: James  |  Next review: James