1, 2, and 3 John

AdvancedBusy pastorsStrong recommendation
Bible Book: 1 John 2 John 3 John
Publisher: Lexham Press
Theological Perspective: Broadly Evangelical
Resource Type: Commentary
Last updated: February 22, 2026
Looking for alternatives? Compare 1 John commentaries.

Evaluation

Overall Score: 8.2/10

Publication Date(s): 2012
Pages: 800
ISBN: 9781577995753
Faithfulness to the Text: 8.4/10
Strong effort to track structure and logic, especially in 1 John recurring themes.
Christ Centredness: 8.6/10
Keeps Christ advocacy and cleansing close to assurance and obedience.
Depth of Insight: 8.3/10
Good depth across all three letters, with helpful synthesis of key themes.
Clarity of Writing: 7.9/10
Generally clear, though occasional density where interpretive issues are discussed.
Pastoral Usefulness: 8.5/10
Particularly helpful for preaching assurance and warning without distortion.
Readability: 7.7/10
Readable for pastors, but best used with time to follow the argument carefully.

Summary

At a Glance

Length
800 pages
Type
Exegetical (Technical)
Theo. Perspective
Broadly Evangelical
Overall score
8.2 / 10

The letters of John are deceptively simple. The vocabulary is plain, the sentences are short, and yet the theology runs deep. A commentary on 1 John must keep two realities in view. First, the letter is written to give assurance through Christ. Second, it is written to expose false claims and false teachers through tests of truth, obedience, and love. If you lean too far into comfort, you blunt the warnings. If you lean too far into tests, you crush the bruised reed. The best work holds both together and keeps Christ at the centre.

This volume covers 1, 2, and 3 John with an aim toward careful explanation and pastoral clarity. In 1 John, it helps you follow the spiralling argument, where themes return and deepen rather than march forward in a straight line. In 2 and 3 John, it helps you see how brief letters can carry sharp instruction about hospitality, loyalty to apostolic truth, and the danger of domineering leadership.

For preachers, 1 John is a gift to the church. It clarifies what fellowship with God looks like, it exposes the lie that sin is trivial, and it insists that love for the brethren is not optional. Yet it also insists that the blood of Jesus cleanses, that Christ is our advocate, and that the Father love is not fragile. A commentary that keeps those emphases joined will serve both pulpit and counselling room.

Strengths

The strongest contribution is the attempt to map the logic of 1 John without forcing it into an artificial outline. Many sermons struggle here because 1 John does not behave like a Pauline argument. This volume helps you identify units, transitions, and recurring markers so that your preaching can be both faithful and comprehensible.

A second strength is attention to the pastoral purpose behind the tests. The tests are not a ladder by which we climb into acceptance. They are a light that exposes false confidence and a mirror that helps genuine believers see the marks of God work in them. That distinction matters for assurance preaching. If you mis-handle it, you either create hypocrisy or despair. A commentary that keeps reminding you of the letter stated purpose is doing real pastoral service.

A third strength is the inclusion of 2 and 3 John in the same volume, with enough depth to treat their unique concerns. These short letters are often ignored, but they are sharply relevant. They speak about truth, love, hospitality, and the abuse of influence. Those themes are not optional for churches that want to be both faithful and warm.

Limitations

The level of detail can be more than some will need for weekly preparation, especially for those who want a slimmer, more homiletical guide. You may find yourself skipping parts when time is tight. Also, some interpretive choices in Johannine studies can be contested, and you may want a second commentary if you are teaching in a context where those debates will surface.

Another limitation is that 1 John invites careful theological synthesis across the Gospel and the wider canon. A commentary can only do so much within the bounds of the letters themselves. You may still want to pair this with a biblical theology resource when planning a longer series.

How We Would Use It

Use it to prepare sermons that keep assurance and warning together. Let the commentary help you decide what the text is doing in each unit, and then build application that matches the aim. In 2 and 3 John, use it to handle hospitality and leadership themes with specificity, especially where churches have been burned by manipulative personalities or confused by a false opposition between truth and love.

This volume also works for training leaders. The letters are short enough to teach in a module, and the commentary provides the scaffolding needed to model careful Bible handling.

Closing Recommendation

This is a serious resource for those who want to preach and teach John letters with clarity and care. It helps you respect the shape of the argument, it keeps the tests from becoming a weapon, and it supports the pastoral aim of John, namely, that God people might know they have eternal life and walk in the light with joy.

Where to buy
exlib_wtb_inserted

Classification

  • Level: Advanced
  • Best For: Busy pastors
  • Priority: Strong recommendation

Build your shelf for this Bible book

Top picks connected to this Bible book, plus a few trusted global staples.

Commentary

Bible Atlas

Reviewed by

An Expositor

↑ Back to the top
Previous review: 1-3 John  |  Next review: 1-3 John