Commentary Reviews

Reset

The First Book Of Samuel

AdvancedAdvanced students / scholars, Busy pastors, Pastors-in-trainingStrong recommendation
7.8Author: David Toshio Tsumura Bible Book: 1 Samuel Publisher: Eerdmans Type: Academic Theological Perspective: Broadly Evangelical

Summary

David Toshio Tsumura’s First Samuel in the NICOT series is a meticulous, academically rich, and linguistically precise exposition of this pivotal historical book. We find it a commentary deeply rooted in the Hebrew text, offering pastors and students a trustworthy guide through the narrative complexity, theological depth, and literary artistry of 1 Samuel. Tsumura’s work is grounded in broadly evangelical commitments, combining rigorous scholarship with a clear respect for the canonical shape of Scripture.

The commentary excels in clarifying historical and philological issues while giving careful attention to narrative structure and character development. It is particularly valuable for those seeking to understand the transition from judges to kingship and the theological themes that undergird Israel’s early monarchy.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

Tsumura brings formidable linguistic skills to the text, offering explanations of Hebrew syntax, vocabulary, and grammar that strengthen a preacher’s confidence in interpretation. Yet despite its technical depth, the commentary remains accessible enough for patient readers who want to dig into the text responsibly.

His treatment of Samuel, Saul, and David is especially insightful. Tsumura highlights the theological threads woven through the narrative—God’s sovereignty, the nature of true leadership, the danger of disobedience, and the surprising patterns of divine election. He consistently points readers to the theological message of the text rather than allowing historical debate to dominate the discussion.

Another strength is Tsumura’s balanced engagement with critical scholarship. He neither ignores difficult questions nor allows speculative theories to overshadow the narrative’s inspired coherence. His steady focus on what the text actually says makes this volume highly dependable for preaching and teaching.

Closing Recommendation

We warmly commend Tsumura’s *First Samuel* as one of the strongest technical-yet-usable commentaries on the book. It offers clarity for pastors preparing to preach, depth for advanced students, and theological integrity throughout.

For anyone seeking a robust and faithful guide to the rise of Israel’s monarchy and the rich theology of 1 Samuel, this commentary is a highly valuable addition to the study shelf.


🛒 Purchase here

The Book Of Ruth

Mid-levelBusy pastors, Lay readers / small groups, Pastors-in-trainingStrong recommendation
8.4Author: Robert L. Hubbard Bible Book: Ruth Series: New International Commentary On The Old Testament Publisher: Eerdmans Type: Exegetical (Technical), Expositional Theological Perspective: Broadly Evangelical

Summary

Robert L. Hubbard Jr.’s Ruth in the NICOT series is a beautifully crafted, academically responsible, and pastorally sensitive exposition of this cherished Old Testament book. We find it a commentary that combines rigorous linguistic work with warm theological insight, helping readers appreciate the narrative artistry and covenant theology that shape the story of Ruth. Hubbard writes from a broadly evangelical standpoint, offering a faithful and engaging treatment that serves pastors, teachers, and thoughtful Christians alike.

The commentary highlights the literary sophistication of Ruth while situating it firmly within the larger redemptive storyline. Hubbard’s attention to structure, character development, and the book’s theological themes gives readers a rich understanding of how God’s providence and kindness are woven through the narrative.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

Hubbard excels at showing how Ruth is far more than a simple love story. He demonstrates its theological depth—its portrayal of loyal love, covenant faithfulness, and the surprising grace of God reaching into the margins of Israel’s life. His exposition helps preachers appreciate how each scene contributes to the book’s movement from emptiness to fullness.

The commentary is especially strong in its analysis of Hebrew narrative technique. Hubbard’s careful work on the text brings clarity to key words, literary motifs, and structural features that shape the book’s impact. Yet he never loses sight of the pastoral importance of the story: the hope it offers to the suffering, the dignity it gives to the overlooked, and the assurance it provides of God’s steadfast commitment to His people.

Hubbard’s engagement with scholarship is balanced and discerning. He interacts with alternative views without overwhelming the reader or distracting from the message of the book. Pastors will benefit from his clear explanations, thoughtful thematic summaries, and sensitivity to the theological richness of Ruth.

Closing Recommendation

We strongly commend Hubbard’s volume as one of the finest evangelical treatments of Ruth available. It offers depth for the preacher, clarity for the student, and warmth for any believer seeking to understand God’s redeeming grace in the everyday details of life.

For those preparing to preach or study Ruth, this commentary provides a trustworthy and illuminating guide—rich, careful, and consistently edifying.


🛒 Purchase here

The Book Of Joshua

AdvancedAdvanced students / scholars, Busy pastors, Pastors-in-trainingStrong recommendation
8.2Author: Marten H. Woudstra Bible Book: Joshua Series: New International Commentary On The Old Testament Publisher: Eerdmans Type: Exegetical (Technical), Expositional Theological Perspective: Broadly Evangelical

Summary

Marten H. Woudstra’s Joshua in the NICOT series is a careful, reverent, and deeply informed exposition of Israel’s entry into the land. We find it a commentary marked by confessional steadiness, linguistic competence, and a clear understanding of Joshua’s place within the unfolding covenant story. Written from a broadly Reformed perspective, it offers pastors and students a reliable guide through a book often misunderstood or mishandled in the contemporary church.

Woudstra balances detailed exegesis with theological attentiveness, setting the narratives of conquest and inheritance within the larger framework of God’s promises to Abraham and the covenantal faithfulness that shapes Israel’s identity.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

This volume excels in its sensitivity to the theological pulse of Joshua. Woudstra shows how the book is not primarily about military triumphs but about God’s sovereign fulfilment of His word and the call to courageous obedience. His careful attention to structure—especially the division between conquest, allotment, and covenant renewal—provides preachers with clarity and confidence when planning a series.

Woudstra engages critical scholarship without being dominated by it. He treats the canonical text with respect, avoiding speculative reconstructions and instead emphasising the theological coherence of the book. His exposition illuminates key themes such as holiness, inheritance, leadership, and the faithfulness of God across generations.

Although written several decades ago, the commentary remains fresh in tone, rich in substance, and enduringly helpful for those who want to preach Joshua with integrity. It offers depth without obscurity and serves both the academy and the church with commendable clarity.

Closing Recommendation

We warmly commend Woudstra’s *Joshua* as one of the finest evangelical expositions of this book. It is especially valuable for pastors and advanced students who desire a commentary that is academically responsible, theologically grounded, and pastorally beneficial.

For anyone preparing to teach Joshua in the local church, this volume will prove a steady companion—clear, faithful, and deeply nourishing.


🛒 Purchase here

The Book Of Deuteronomy

Mid-levelBusy pastors, General readers, Pastors-in-trainingStrong recommendation
8.2Author: Peter C. Craigie Bible Book: Deuteronomy Series: New International Commentary On The Old Testament Publisher: Eerdmans Type: Exegetical (Technical), Expositional Theological Perspective: Broadly Evangelical

Summary

Peter C. Craigie’s The Book of Deuteronomy in the NICOT series is a thoughtful, disciplined exposition of one of Scripture’s most formative books. We find it a model of careful evangelical scholarship—rich in historical insight, attentive to literary structure, and deeply aware of Deuteronomy’s covenantal heartbeat. Written with clarity and restraint, it serves pastors, students, and serious readers who want to understand how Deuteronomy speaks both in its ancient setting and within the whole counsel of God.

Craigie approaches the text with reverence, working closely with the Hebrew while keeping the commentary readable. His handling of Moses’ sermons, the law sections, and the theological emphases of the book consistently reflects a commitment to Scripture’s authority and unity.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

We value Craigie’s ability to synthesise scholarship without overwhelming the reader. He brings out the pastoral and theological pulse of Deuteronomy—its call to remember, obey, and walk in covenant fidelity—while avoiding speculative reconstructions. His discussions of structure, setting, and key themes give preachers solid footing when navigating the book’s density.

The commentary is especially strong in showing how Deuteronomy frames the Old Testament story and shapes Israel’s worship, ethics, and identity. Craigie’s exposition helps readers see why this book stands at the threshold of the Old Testament canon, echoing throughout the prophets, the Psalms, and the ministry of Jesus.

Although more concise than later NICOT volumes, its very simplicity makes it a dependable companion for sermon preparation, Bible study leadership, and personal study. Craigie’s even-handed judgement and theological steadiness make this a trustworthy guide for those seeking clarity and depth.

Closing Recommendation

We warmly commend this volume as an excellent entry point into preaching or studying Deuteronomy. It may not answer every technical question, but its clarity, reliability, and pastoral usefulness make it one of the most accessible and enduring commentaries on this foundational book.

Pastors, students, and thoughtful readers alike will benefit from Craigie’s careful exposition and his evident desire to help the church hear the living voice of God in Deuteronomy.


🛒 Purchase here

The Book Of Numbers

AdvancedAdvanced students / scholars, Busy pastors, Pastors-in-trainingStrong recommendation
8.2Author: Timothy R. Ashley Bible Book: Numbers Series: New International Commentary On The Old Testament Publisher: Eerdmans Type: Academic Theological Perspective: Broadly Evangelical

Summary

Timothy R. Ashley’s The Book of Numbers in the NICOT series is a substantial, academically informed commentary that combines careful exegesis with a broadly evangelical commitment to the authority of Scripture. We find it a comprehensive and steady guide through one of the Old Testament’s more complex books, serving pastors, students, and serious readers who want to wrestle with the text in its literary and theological depth.

Ashley works closely with the Hebrew text, attends to structure, narrative flow, and historical context, and offers a balanced engagement with scholarly debates without overwhelming the reader. While primarily technical in orientation, the commentary remains attentive to the theological message of Numbers and its place within the Pentateuch.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

We appreciate Ashley’s combination of philological care and theological awareness. His explanations of difficult passages—whether in the wilderness narratives, the laws, or the census materials—give preachers confidence that they are handling the text responsibly. He regularly clarifies interpretive options and demonstrates why one reading better accounts for the literary and theological shape of the book.

The commentary’s strength lies in its even-handedness: Ashley neither flattens difficulties nor indulges speculative reconstruction. He treats the canonical form of Numbers with respect, helping readers see its coherence, movement, and ongoing significance for the people of God.

Pastors will benefit from his discussions of structure and intention, especially in sections where preaching can feel daunting. Though not overtly devotional, the commentary repeatedly draws attention to God’s holiness, patience, discipline, and covenant faithfulness.

Closing Recommendation

For those preaching or studying Numbers at depth, this is a reliable, weighty companion. It requires slow reading but rewards it richly, especially for ministers and advanced students wanting a detailed, text-driven exposition grounded in sound evangelical scholarship.

We warmly commend it as a strong resource for sustained study of Numbers and an excellent addition to any serious Old Testament library.


🛒 Purchase here

Genesis: Christian Beginnings

Mid-levelBusy pastorsTop choice
9.0Author: William J.U. Philip Bible Book: Genesis Publisher: Tron Books Type: Expository (Mid-Level), Homiletical Theological Perspective: Broadly Evangelical, Reformed

Summary

Genesis: Christian Beginnings is a substantial, preacher-shaped walk through the whole of Genesis from a clearly Reformed, Christ-focused pastor. Philip treats Genesis as the book of beginnings for the entire Bible storyline, tracing how creation, fall, covenant, and promise all anticipate the gospel of Christ.

This is not a technical commentary, but a carefully argued expository work that keeps an open Bible and a Sunday congregation in view. The exegesis is grounded in the text, alert to structure and context, and consistently asking, “How does this passage preach Christ with integrity?”

Across its length, the book moves steadily from explanation to implication. It aims to equip preachers and thoughtful readers to handle Genesis with confidence, rather than to overwhelm them with academic detail.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

First, this volume gives you a clear, big-picture framework for Genesis. Philip regularly stands back to show how individual episodes fit the larger movements of the book—primeval history, the call of Abraham, the patriarchal narratives, and the development of God’s covenant promises. That macro-structure is gold for planning series, setting up sermon units, and avoiding a string of disconnected stories.

Second, the exposition is consistently Christ-centred without being forced. Philip shows how Genesis prepares the way for the Lord Jesus through promise, pattern, and typology, but he does so with textual restraint. The result is preaching help that honours authorial intent and still leads God’s people to Christ, not moralism.

Third, this commentary thinks like a pastor. Repeatedly, Philip presses home the pastoral weight of a passage—how Genesis exposes idolatry, comforts the weary, humbles the proud, and stabilises God’s people in his sovereign promises. Applications are concrete and church-aware, not abstract reflections. Busy preachers will find sermon trajectories, not just exegetical notes.

Finally, the writing is clear and engaging. Theological categories are explained, not assumed; Hebrew and technical matters are handled briefly and folded into the flow rather than derailing it. The length allows space for careful reflection, but the tone remains warm, direct, and focused on the life of the local church.

Closing Recommendation

We would warmly commend Genesis: Christian Beginnings as a serious yet accessible exposition of Genesis from a trusted Reformed pastor. It will particularly help those preaching through the book, or planning to, who want more than sermon outlines but less than a technical reference work.

If you are a pastor or preacher in a Reformed or broadly evangelical setting, this deserves a prominent place on your Genesis shelf. As a first substantial exposition alongside a more technical resource, it will serve you, and your people, very well.


🛒 Purchase here

Romans 1-8 Commentary Review

Mid-levelBusy pastors, General readers, Pastors-in-trainingUseful supplement
8.1Author: John MacArthur Bible Book: Romans Series: MacArthur Commentary On The New Testament Publisher: Moody Publishers Type: Expositional, Expository (Mid-Level), Homiletical Theological Perspective: Baptist, Broadly Evangelical, Reformed

Summary

The commentary on Romans 1-8 by John MacArthur, published by Moody Publishers in 1991, covers the first eight chapters of the apostle Paul’s epistle to the Romans. MacArthur’s treatment is verse-by-verse, doctrinally robust, and intends to be pastorally useful. The commentary is rooted firmly in evangelical orthodoxy and addresses the foundational themes of sin, grace, justification, sanctification and the believer’s life in Christ.

In format it is expository with clear exegetical underpinnings: MacArthur engages each section of the text, highlights interpretive issues, summarizes key theological points, and frequently pivots to application for church‐life and personal discipleship. It is not a highly technical academic work filled with Greek and Hebrew apparatus, but it is neither superficial—it walks a fine line between scholarship and practical ministry.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

Firstly, for the preacher or teacher who desires a commentary that is both theologically serious and practically minded, this volume offers depth without becoming unhelpfully dense. MacArthur’s commitment to the gospel of Christ and to the sovereignty of God shines through, making the text not merely a commentary but a resource for proclamation and pastoral care.

Secondly, because Romans chapters 1–8 present so many of the core themes of the Christian life—sin, condemnation, justification, union with Christ, sanctification—the resource works well in sermon preparation, Bible study leadership, and pastoral training. The commentary doesn’t shy away from difficult doctrinal matters (such as imputation, the role of the law, righteousness of God) and so helps the teacher ground the exposition in historic biblical theology.

Thirdly, while MacArthur’s perspective is clear and firm (and not every reader will agree with every emphatic expression), the commentary remains accessible. For pastors working under time pressure or mature lay-leaders wanting to deepen their exposition of Romans, this volume is more usable than many purely academic tomes while offering more substance than the light devotional commentary.

Closing Recommendation

We recommend this commentary strongly for those in pastoral ministry, evangelistic teaching, or adult Christian education who embrace a conservative evangelical framework and wish to teach Romans 1–8 with clarity and gospel‐intensity. It complements more technical commentaries by anchoring the exposition in sound doctrine and application.

That said, if one’s goal is cutting-edge critical scholarship or original‐language heavy exegesis, this is not the most specialised option. But as a work balancing doctrinal fidelity, practical utility, and readability, we believe it is very much worth acquiring and using alongside other resources.


🛒 Purchase here

Revelation

Mid-levelBusy pastors, General readers, Pastors-in-trainingStrong recommendation
8.8Author: Simon J. Kistemaker Bible Book: Revelation Series: New Testament Commentary (Hendriksen Kistemaker Series) Publisher: Baker Book House Type: Expositional Theological Perspective: Broadly Evangelical, Reformed

Summary

Simon Kistemaker’s volume on Revelation in the Hendriksen–Kistemaker New Testament Commentary series offers a clear, steady, and pastorally sensitive guide through one of Scripture’s most challenging books. We find here an exposition shaped by careful exegesis, sober restraint, and a deep confidence in the sovereign triumph of Christ.

Kistemaker anchors his work in a redemptive-historical reading of Revelation, constantly drawing the reader back to the central theme: the Lamb reigns. Rather than indulging speculation, he emphasises the book’s encouragement to suffering saints and the certainty of God’s unfolding purposes.

This commentary serves pastors, teachers, and thoughtful believers who want solid exposition without being overwhelmed by technical complexities.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

First, Kistemaker offers clarity where many commentators offer complexity. He explains symbolism with care, shows how the Old Testament shapes John’s vision, and provides a theological compass rooted in Christ’s kingship. His approach is consistently reverent, grounded, and oriented toward the text rather than contemporary sensationalism.

Second, this commentary is highly serviceable for sermon preparation. Kistemaker draws out pastoral implications with maturity, helping preachers see how Revelation strengthens faith, steadies hope, and deepens endurance. He writes with an awareness that this book is meant to comfort the church—not confuse it.

Third, Kistemaker strikes a fruitful balance between scholarly engagement and accessible exposition. He interacts with major interpretive positions, but always with a gentle hand, keeping the focus on the message rather than the debate.

Closing Recommendation

We warmly commend this commentary to pastors and teachers seeking a reliable, Christ-exalting guide through Revelation. It offers substance without unnecessary weight, and clarity without oversimplification.

If you want a commentary that strengthens confidence in God’s sovereignty, nurtures worship, and equips you to preach Revelation with conviction, this volume deserves a prominent place on your shelf.

🛒 Purchase here

James, Epistles of John, Peter, and Jude

Mid-levelBusy pastors, Lay readers / small groups, Pastors-in-trainingStrong recommendation
8.4Author: Simon J. Kistemaker Bible Book: 1 John, 1 Peter, 2 John, 2 Peter, 3 John, James, Jude Series: New Testament Commentary (Hendriksen Kistemaker Series) Publisher: Baker Book House Type: Expositional, Expository (Mid-Level) Theological Perspective: Reformed

Summary

Simon J. Kistemaker’s volume James, Epistles of John, Peter, and Jude in the New Testament Commentary series (Baker Book House) offers a full exposition of these General Epistles in one substantial hardback. First published in 1996, it provides verse-by-verse commentary on James; 1–3 John; 1–2 Peter; and Jude, written from a clearly Reformed, evangelical standpoint and aimed chiefly at pastors, Bible teachers, and serious students.

Kistemaker combines careful exegesis with a pastoral tone, explaining the flow of argument in each letter and drawing out their major themes: living faith and works (James), truth and love in the church (1–3 John), suffering and hope (1–2 Peter), and contending for the faith (Jude). The result is a single, coherent resource for handling some of the New Testament’s most searching and practical writings.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

We value this commentary first for its doctrinal steadiness. Kistemaker writes within a confessional Reformed framework, treating these epistles as inspired Scripture and giving full weight to their teaching on repentance, holiness, perseverance, and the testing of genuine faith. His handling of James is balanced—emphasising that works flow from justifying faith rather than competing with it—and his exposition of the Johannine epistles carefully holds together assurance, obedience, and love in the life of the believer.

Second, it is very usable in the study. The commentary follows the text closely, with clear section headings, straightforward explanations, and judicious use of Greek where it sheds real light on the passage. Preachers will find help in navigating difficult issues such as trials and temptation, the tongue, false teaching, church conflict, and the call to steadfastness under pressure. Kistemaker regularly moves from explanation to implication, giving natural launch-points for sermons and Bible studies.

Third, the one-volume scope across several letters is genuinely practical. For those planning a preaching series in James, 1 John, 1 Peter, or Jude—or dipping into these books repeatedly over the years—having a single, theologically aligned companion is a real advantage. While it does not attempt exhaustive engagement with every scholarly debate, it offers enough substance to give preachers confidence that they are on solid ground.

Closing Recommendation

We recommend this volume warmly for pastors, elders, and serious Bible-study leaders in Reformed and broadly evangelical churches who want clear, trustworthy exposition of these General Epistles. It will serve particularly well as a primary mid-level commentary for sermon preparation and teaching.

Those engaged in academic research or seeking the most technical linguistic work may wish to supplement it with more specialised volumes. But as a core ministry resource—combining doctrinal integrity, clarity of exposition, and pastoral usefulness—Kistemaker’s James, Epistles of John, Peter, and Jude remains an excellent addition to a working library.


🛒 Purchase here

Hebrews

Mid-levelBusy pastors, Lay readers / small groups, Pastors-in-trainingStrong recommendation
8.8Author: Simon J. Kistemaker Bible Book: Hebrews Series: New Testament Commentary (Hendriksen Kistemaker Series) Publisher: Baker Book House Type: Expositional, Expository (Mid-Level) Theological Perspective: Reformed

Summary

Simon J. Kistemaker’s Hebrews (Baker Book House, 1984) in the New Testament Commentary series is a warm, accessible, pastor-friendly exposition of one of the most demanding books in Scripture. Writing from a Reformed evangelical standpoint, Kistemaker unfolds the argument of Hebrews with patience and clarity, tracing the author’s presentation of Jesus as the perfect High Priest, the fulfilment of the Old Covenant, and the anchor of the believer’s hope. His treatment offers a dependable bridge between scholarly understanding and pastoral application.

The commentary proceeds verse by verse, giving attention to structure, Old Testament background, and theological coherence. While not a technical monograph, it provides solid guidance for teachers and preachers seeking to navigate the deep Christology and pastoral exhortations of Hebrews.

Why Should I Own This Commentary?

We commend this volume first for its Christ-centred clarity. Kistemaker consistently draws out the supremacy, priesthood and sacrificial work of Christ—the heart of Hebrews—without drifting into speculative tangents. His discussions on chapters 4–10, in particular, offer clear explanations of the priestly office, covenant theology, and the superiority of Christ’s once-for-all sacrifice.

For preaching and teaching, this commentary is especially useful. Kistemaker explains the text with pastoral sensitivity, identifies the author’s argument in each section, and offers application that naturally grows from the passage. Difficult portions—warnings, perseverance, apostasy, Melchizedek—are handled with care and doctrinal steadiness, making the commentary suitable for ministry in Reformed evangelical churches.

Though not the most academically technical treatment of Hebrews, it offers enough engagement with key issues to orient the preacher, while maintaining readability for sustained sermon series. Its steady combination of exposition and theology makes it a reliable companion for those teaching the book.

Closing Recommendation

We warmly recommend this commentary to pastors, elders and Bible teachers who desire a trustworthy, Christ-centred exposition of Hebrews. It is particularly valuable for those seeking a mid-level commentary that lends itself naturally to preaching and pastoral ministry.

Those requiring heavy engagement with Greek linguistics or advanced scholarly debate may wish to supplement with more technical works, but as a core resource for faithful exposition, Kistemaker’s *Hebrews* remains an excellent choice.


🛒 Purchase here