Evaluation
Overall Score: 8.5/10
Summary
At a Glance
- Length
- 570 pages
- Type
- Expository
- Theo. Perspective
- Reformed
- Overall score
- 8.5 / 10
Romans is not a book we can afford to handle casually. It is doctrinally dense, pastorally tender, and relentlessly God centred. John V. Fesko writes with that reality in view. This volume aims to help preachers keep the argument of Romans visible while also serving the church’s need for clear gospel proclamation. We found it strongest when it refuses to treat Romans as a slogan factory. Instead, it asks us to follow Paul’s reasoning, paragraph by paragraph, and then to let that reasoning shape the tone of our preaching.
Fesko reads Romans as a coherent letter that moves from the revelation of God’s righteousness to the life of faith, union with Christ, the work of the Spirit, God’s sovereign mercy, and the practical obedience that flows from worship. He is alert to the way Paul presses both humility and confidence. We are humbled because salvation is of the Lord. We are confident because the Lord has acted decisively in Christ, and His promises do not wobble under pressure.
Because this is a pastoral commentary in an expository series, it rarely gets lost in technical argument for its own sake. Where interpretive decisions matter, Fesko explains them with enough clarity to support preaching, and then he moves on. That is a gift to busy pastors. We still need deeper technical tools at times, but we are not left without help in handling the difficult turns, especially where Romans is frequently misused in controversy or flattened into abstract theology.
Strengths
First, the commentary is strong in doctrinal clarity without drifting into coldness. Romans can tempt us into detached analysis. Fesko repeatedly brings the letter back to worship, assurance, and the new obedience of faith. That supports a Reformed approach that is both confessional and warmly evangelical. We are not only learning categories. We are being called to trust Christ, to walk by the Spirit, and to live as a people whose hope is grounded in God’s saving purpose.
Second, Fesko is careful with the big Reformed themes that Romans carries, justification, union with Christ, sanctification, and election. He does not handle those themes as weapons. He treats them as pastoral realities meant to produce humility, gratitude, and perseverance. In Romans 8, for example, the comfort of adoption, the intercession of the Spirit, and the certainty of God’s love are not presented as mere proofs. They are presented as the living support of weary saints, including weary pastors.
Third, this volume helps with preaching the flow. Romans is full of famous verses, but famous verses can become isolated. Fesko helps us see how the famous lines sit inside a wider argument. That strengthens exposition. It also protects application from becoming moralistic or therapeutic. When the gospel is kept central, the call to obedience in Romans 12 to 15 sounds like gratitude, not self rescue.
Limitations
The primary limitation is that some sections will still leave advanced students wanting more engagement with scholarly debate. That is not a flaw in the aim of the series, but it does mean this cannot be the only companion on Romans if you are doing extended teaching, or if your congregation is pressing hard questions about disputed texts. A second limitation is that the pace can feel brisk in certain doctrinally weighty passages. You may want to slow down and supplement with a more detailed commentary when preparing for preaching through Romans 9 to 11, not because Fesko is careless, but because those chapters demand careful thought and careful pastoral tone.
How We Would Use It
We would use this as a steady, week by week preaching companion. Read the passage repeatedly, outline Paul’s argument, and then consult Fesko to check the flow, clarify key theological moves, and gather preaching angles that remain faithful to the text. This is also a helpful tool for elders and ministry trainees. The prose is accessible enough to shape how leaders talk about justification, sanctification, assurance, and God’s sovereign mercy without falling into clichés.
We also appreciate this volume for counselling shaped by Romans. When someone is crushed by guilt, Romans does not simply say, “Try harder.” It says, “Look to Christ, He justifies the ungodly.” When someone is terrified by suffering, Romans does not promise easy days. It promises that nothing can separate us from the love of God in Christ. Fesko helps keep those pastoral uses close to the letter’s meaning.
Closing Recommendation
This is a sound, church serving commentary on Romans that will reward careful, prayerful use. It keeps the argument visible, holds doctrine and devotion together, and helps us preach Christ with confidence. We commend it especially for pastors who want a reliable Reformed guide that still feels like it belongs in the pulpit, not only in the classroom.
Build your shelf for this Bible book
Top picks connected to this Bible book, plus a few trusted global staples.