Evaluation
Overall Score: 8.2/10
A profound, faithful, and pastorally rich guide to Hosea that deserves a place in any preacher’s library.
Summary
At a Glance
- Length
- 428 pages
- Type
- Exegetical (Technical), Expository (Mid-Level), Homiletical
- Theo. Perspective
- Broadly Evangelical
- Overall score
- 8.2 / 10
- Strength
- Brings Hosea’s complex prophecy to life through careful exegesis and pastoral theological reflection.
- Limitation
- Dense and theological material may challenge those seeking quick devotional reading.
J. Andrew Dearman’s contribution on Hosea in the New International Commentary On The Old Testament carries real weight. We are led through a book that is both painful and beautiful, a book where covenant grace and covenant grief sit side by side. Dearman pays close attention to the movement of the text and to the world in which Hosea ministered. He brings out the force of the poetry, the sharpness of the metaphors, and the appeal of the prophet who calls God’s people back with urgency and tenderness.
The commentary manages to hold the emotional and theological tension that runs through Hosea. Sin is confronted with clarity. Hope grows slowly but surely as the prophecy unfolds. Dearman guides us with steady explanation, helping the reader trace how the message develops and why each image or oracle carries the weight it does. His work never feels rushed. Instead it gives space for the text to speak and allows the reader to feel the ache and the promise that breathe through Hosea.
Why Should I Own This Commentary?
If you plan to teach Hosea, you will find this volume a strong companion. The introduction gives you what you need. It sets the book in its historical setting, outlines the shape of the prophecy, and explains the covenant framework that governs every part of it. Dearman’s translation and textual notes are clear and careful. He does not get lost in technicalities, yet he does not skim over them either. This balance helps pastors and students understand what matters for exegesis without being overwhelmed.
As the commentary moves through the text, Dearman shows a steady grasp of Hebrew poetry and prophetic rhetoric. He helps you see why certain words are chosen, how images function, and what each section contributes to the whole. He draws attention to God’s holiness, the seriousness of Israel’s unfaithfulness, and the surprising persistence of divine love. These themes rise from the text with conviction and create rich ground for preaching.
Pastors will appreciate the way Dearman handles application. He does not force artificial bridges into the New Testament. Instead he highlights the theological currents that naturally lead toward the gospel, such as covenant restoration and sacrificial love. His comments leave room for pastors to craft sermons that are both faithful to Hosea and alive to the hope fulfilled in Christ.
Closing Recommendation
We commend this commentary to pastors, teachers, and students who want to handle Hosea with honesty and depth. It is serious work, yet not cold. It is careful, yet not dry. Dearman serves the church by helping God’s people hear the voice of a prophet who loved deeply and spoke with clarity. This volume will strengthen anyone who desires to preach Hosea with understanding and conviction.
Classification
- Level: Advanced
- Best For: Advanced students / scholars, Busy pastors, Pastors-in-training
- Priority: Strong recommendation