Summary
We approach Esther needing help with a book that feels both dramatic and subtle. The plot moves quickly, yet the theological weight is often carried through irony, reversal, and quiet providence. A good commentary must help us see the narrative artistry, follow the structure, and preach the book without either flattening it into moral lessons or sidelining it as mere history. This volume is designed to assist that careful work by giving sustained attention to the text and its movement.
In a series that aims to serve evangelical readers with serious engagement, the strengths we look for are consistent. We want a clear grasp of the argument, careful handling of language where it matters, and attention to context, including historical setting and literary design. We also want help in moving from explanation to proclamation in a way that keeps the Lord’s faithfulness central, even when the divine name is not made explicit in the narrative.
Used well, this commentary can help us preach Esther with patience. The book trains us to notice the patterns that drive the story, including feasting and fasting, public honour and public shame, hidden plans and exposed schemes. Those patterns are not decorative. They serve the message that the Lord preserves His people even when they are vulnerable and compromised, and that He does so through ordinary means that may not look glorious at the time.
Strengths
First, we are helped to read the book as a unified narrative with intention. That protects us from cherry picking favourite scenes. Esther is not a collection of inspirational moments. It is a carefully crafted story of reversal. When we preach it, the whole shape matters. This kind of guidance supports preaching that is faithful to the flow rather than driven by our own preferred topics.
Second, the commentary’s careful attention to context can help avoid both naivety and cynicism. Esther includes court politics, personal vulnerability, and morally messy decisions. We need help speaking about those realities with honesty while still holding to God’s sovereign preservation. A serious commentary can help us name the complexity without becoming suspicious of the text. We can acknowledge what is troubling without stepping away from trust in God’s Word.
Third, a work like this can serve pastors by giving them interpretive confidence. Esther is often preached in a thin way, either as a call to courage with little gospel depth, or as a vague story about providence with little textual grounding. We need to show our people why we are saying what we are saying. A fuller commentary supports that work by giving structure, explaining key decisions, and helping us see how themes recur and develop.
Limitations
The main limitation for many pastors will be the time required to use it well. A more detailed commentary demands that we slow down. That is a strength, but it also means this will not always be the first book we open when a deadline is tight. It is best used early in preparation, alongside our own repeated reading of the text.
Another limitation is that a commentary can give information without giving homiletical direction. We still need to do the work of crafting sermons, shaping applications, and finding appropriate tone for our people. This volume can support that work, but it cannot replace it.
How We Would Use It
We would use this as a main desk companion when preaching Esther. Start with repeated reading of the narrative, mapping scenes and reversals. Then consult the commentary for help with structure, interpretive questions, and the flow of themes. We would also use it to avoid simplistic moralising, especially around Esther and Mordecai. Instead, we would aim to show God’s preserving mercy to undeserving people, and the comfort of His hidden hand.
In training contexts, this can help younger preachers learn how to handle narrative carefully, how to read whole scenes, and how to make applications that arise from the text rather than from modern slogans.
Closing Recommendation
This is a substantial tool for those who want to preach Esther with careful attention and serious engagement. It is best suited to pastors and students who are willing to work slowly, so that the clarity of the sermon reflects the clarity of the text.
Anthony J. Tomasino
Anthony J. Tomasino is a North American biblical scholar of the contemporary era, working within broadly evangelical scholarship with a concern for faithful reading.
He has contributed through teaching and writing that helps students grasp the shape of the Old Testament, the flow of its argument, and the way careful exegesis serves the church. His work often aims to bridge the classroom and the pulpit, giving readers tools to read well and to teach with clarity.
He is valued where he steadies readers in method, context, and the discipline of close reading. If you want a guided, text attentive approach that supports exposition, his introductory and teaching oriented resources are a helpful place to begin.
Theological Perspective: Broadly Evangelical