Evaluation

Overall Score: 7.4/10

Publication Date(s): 2007

Pages: 421

ISBN: 9780830814893

Faithfulness to the Text: 6.9/10

Many extracts fit the theological weight of John, but they do not always show the exegetical route. Anchor every insight in the passage itself.

Christ Centredness: 9/10

Christ is central throughout, especially in the prologue and the signs. This can strengthen sermons that aim to set Christ before the congregation.

Depth of Insight: 7.2/10

There are genuine theological depths here, though the brief format limits development. The insights often come as concentrated lines rather than full explanations.

Clarity of Writing: 7.1/10

The extracts are mostly clear, but some assume doctrinal background. Read them with the biblical text open to keep clarity.

Pastoral Usefulness: 7.4/10

Helpful for christological preaching and for addressing unbelief and assurance. Less helpful for detailed exegesis and passage structure.

Readability: 7/10

Readable in sections and easy to consult, though the volume is sizeable. It rewards targeted use tied to your preaching text.

Summary

At a Glance

Length: 421 pages
Type: Theological
Theo. Perspective: Non-Evangelical / Critical
Overall score: 7.4 / 10

This volume presents early Christian commentary on John 1 to 10, arranged by passage. The extracts dwell on the incarnation, the signs, the new birth, the bread of life, and the good shepherd. The approach is theological and devotional, often aimed at protecting christological confession and shaping the church in faith and holiness.

Strengths

For preaching John, the patristic focus on the person of Christ can be a real help. The extracts can sharpen your language for the deity of Christ, the glory of the Word made flesh, and the saving purpose of the signs. Many comments are also pastorally alert, warning against unbelief and encouraging humble faith.

Limitations

The volume is not a modern exegetical commentary. You will not find careful treatment of Greek, historical setting, or Johannine structure. Some extracts lean towards theological controversy of their own day and can feel less connected to the immediate passage. The catena style also means you must do the work of synthesis.

How We Would Use It

Begin with close reading in John and use a solid modern commentary for structure and context. Then consult this volume to deepen christological proclamation and to gather historic pastoral reflections. It can be especially useful when preaching the prologue or the major discourses.

Closing Recommendation

A rich theological supplement for advanced readers, with clear benefits for christological preaching. Use it with discernment and keep your exposition anchored in the text.

Where to buy

Amazon Logos