1 Samuel

Summary

First Samuel is a book of transitions, from judges to kingship, from scattered leadership to central authority, and from hope to painful lessons about the kind of king Israel truly needs. Harry A. Hoffner’s treatment in the Evangelical Exegetical Commentary aims to serve pastors and teachers who want to follow the book’s argument rather than treating it as a collection of famous stories. We meet Hannah’s prayer, the corruption of Eli’s sons, the rise and fall of Saul, and the steady shaping of David. Yet the real centre is the Lord Himself, the One who opposes the proud and gives grace to the humble.

This commentary is most helpful when it keeps that centre visible. It encourages us to read narrative as theology in motion. The Lord is not a background character. He is judging, guiding, restraining, and revealing His purposes. Hoffner helps us notice the repeated contrasts, humble and proud, obedient and self preserving, fear of the Lord and fear of people. Those contrasts are not moralistic slogans. They are woven into the plot so that we feel the weight of what covenant faithfulness looks like in real life.

There is also a strong sense of the book’s pastoral realism. Leaders are flawed. People are fickle. The temptation to use religious language while disobeying is always near. Saul is a warning that can preach in any generation, especially in settings where leadership is prized and character is assumed. David is not presented as perfect, but as the Lord’s chosen king, shaped by suffering, waiting, and trust. The commentary helps us keep the narrative tension, which is where faithful preaching often lives.

Strengths

First, the scale of the work allows for careful attention to detail without losing the storyline. At over a thousand pages, this is not a light tool, yet the best sections show how close reading serves the big picture. That is ideal for series preaching. We can plan units with confidence and avoid the common trap of over preaching the dramatic moments while neglecting the quieter shaping chapters.

Second, the exposition tends to be clear about narrative purpose. We are helped to see why certain speeches, summaries, and repeated phrases are included. That matters because narrative preaching can drift into retelling without explaining meaning. Hoffner pushes us to ask what the author is emphasising, what response is being called for, and what kind of king the Lord is preparing His people to desire.

Third, there is pastoral usefulness in the way leadership themes are handled. The commentary provides material for training elders, for correcting shallow leadership models, and for helping congregations understand that outward success can hide inward compromise. It also helps us apply the book beyond leadership, because the heart issues are common to all believers, fear, impatience, self justification, and forgetfulness of the Lord.

Limitations

The size can be a drawback for busy pastors. You may not have time to consult this in full each week. It is a commentary that rewards early preparation and a planned series, rather than last minute rescue. At points, the amount of detail can also feel uneven, with some discussions expanding more than a preacher may need. This is where selective use becomes wise.

How We Would Use It

We would use this commentary primarily at the planning stage, mapping the book’s structure, identifying major turns, and clarifying interpretive decisions that shape the sermon series. Week to week, we would dip in for the key chapters, especially where narrative complexity and theological emphasis meet. It is also a strong resource for training men who are learning to handle Old Testament narrative with precision and restraint.

In preaching, we would use the commentary as a guardrail. It helps keep us from turning Samuel into a leadership seminar, and it helps us keep the Lord’s kingship and covenant purposes in the foreground. That is where Christian proclamation finds its true line of connection to Christ, the final King who is faithful where Saul was faithless and who is humble where human hearts are proud.

Closing Recommendation

We commend this as a substantial mid level resource for serious work in 1 Samuel. It is not quick, but it is capable of strengthening both understanding and proclamation when used with patience and a clear plan.